About
Learn More about our progressive online community for the Granite State.

Create an account today (it's free and easy) and get started!
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Search




Advanced Search


The Masthead
Managing Editors
Dean Barker
Laura Clawson
Jennifer Daler

Contributing Writers
elwood
Mike Hoefer
susanthe
William Tucker

ActBlue Hampshire

The Roll, Etc.
Prog Blogs, Orgs & Alumni
Bank Slate
Betsy Devine
birch, finch, beech
Blue News Tribune (MA)
Democracy for NH
Live Free or Die
Mike Caulfield
Miscellany Blue
Granite State Progress
Seacoast for Change
Susan the Bruce
Tomorrow's Progressives

Politicos & Punditry
The Burt Cohen Show
John Gregg
Krauss
Landrigan
Lawson
Pindell
Primary Monitor
Primary Wire
Scala
Schoenberg
Spiliotes
Welch

Campaigns, Et Alia.
Paul Hodes
Carol Shea-Porter
Ann McLane Kuster
Katrina Swett
Jennifer Daler

ActBlue Hampshire
NHDP
DCCC
DSCC
DNC

National
Balloon Juice
billmon
Congress Matters
DailyKos
Digby
Hold Fast
Eschaton
FiveThirtyEight
MyDD
The Next Hurrah
Open Left
Senate Guru
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo

50 State Blog Network
Alabama
Arizona
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Missouri
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin

Memo For Hillary Clinton: It's About Ideas

by: Rep. Jim Splaine

Wed Nov 21, 2007 at 22:24:34 PM EST


First, to be up front and in the interest of full disclosure, I'll mention that I'm supporting Hillary Clinton for President.  I was one of her very early endorsers, dating back to a Blog post I wrote on December 5, 2006, even before her announcement of January 20th six weeks later.

In fact, I sort of endorsed her for President the very first time I met her in a small group meeting in Portsmouth in 1991, when she was campaigning for a little-known Governor.  After her comments as she was leaving I said she should be the candidate for President.  She laughed.  Just a bit.

I like Hillary Clinton for a number of reasons, which I'll summarize in the next few weeks.  I think she's done great things, and I believe that she can win next November.  I do happen to also like all of the other Democratic Presidential candidates.  Those of us who are Democrats are rich with good men and women who want to be our leaders.

However, as one New Hampshire voter, I'd like to offer some advice to Hillary Clinton.  I'll say it this way:  Hillary, your "EXPERIENCE" slogan won't work.  It won't get you elected.  In Iowa and New Hampshire, it won't put it away for you.  We're looking for more than that in our next President.  We look at the candidates eye-to-eye, face-to-face.   We listen carefully to your answers to our questions.  That's OUR experience.

Saying you're more "experienced" than Barack Obama or John Edwards or other candidates isn't going to get people to vote for you, because in Politics 21st Century, ideas count more than ever.  Ideas will get us out of Iraq, sooner than later.  Ideas will get us heath care, real not imagined.  Ideas will create an educational system that will prepare our kids for the 22nd Century that many of them will touch, and in which their own children will compete.

Hillary, you've got some tough opponents in the Democratic primaries and caucuses, and they have lots of ideas.  You COULD lose the nomination -- and it's probably yours to lose.  

Some of your opponents present their ideas better than you present your "experience."  You talk a lot about experience, but I'd like to hear more about your ideas, including the new ideas you have.  And you do have some, but we have to look real hard because you spend most of your time talking about your experience.

As a sports enthusiast, I don't care so much about what an aging baseball player might have in the form of past records or years of experience; come the World Series what matters most is what he's going to do in the upcoming game.  Sometimes his experience might help in deciding that next pitch, but usually it comes down to focusing on the task at hand -- the next hit, the next play, the next run.  That's his real worth on the field.

As a New Hampshire voter, I think that you've got to do the same thing.  Stop telling us about YOUR experience.  Talk with us about OUR future --  the next issue, the next solution, the next hope.

Put your pollsters aside.  Forget the focus groups. Resist the "politically correct" answers where you sound like you're trying to satisfy everyone and every interest group.  Tell your managers you don't want to be managed.  Leave your speech writers' missives at their offices.  Forget the cute one-liners that don't tell us much.  Don't be overly cautious or calculating.  Show your courage, we've seen that before.  Be yourself.  Just yourself.  We'll like what we see.  

This advice is coming from a supporter, so I hope Hillary Clinton and her campaign advisors think about it, before they get the message from the voters and it's too late for her to recover.  Once Iowa's Caucus gets under way on Thursday, January 3rd, there are only 33 days, or 800 hours, give or take a couple, before February 5th when most of the country will have voted in primaries and caucuses.  The race will have been decided by then, perhaps even sooner.  So Hillary, now is the time -- before the first contests in Iowa and New Hampshire -- to get those ideas out.  Please start right away.

So, quick memo to Hillary Clinton for placement on refrigerator:  Challenge us.  Talk with us about America's possibilities and our opportunities.  Give us your vision.  Respect us.  Let us see you for whom you are.  I think we'll like you even more for that.

Rep. Jim Splaine :: Memo For Hillary Clinton: It's About Ideas
Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Standing ovation. (4.00 / 1)
You articulate what it is about Clinton's campaign strategy that keeps me at a distance.  That the arrow, as it were, is pointed in the wrong direction, towards the past and not the future.  But hearing it from a passionate Clinton supporter makes it worth its weight in gold.

Oddly enough, your diary makes me more interested in Clinton the person and possible president than the very aspects of the campaign that are at issue here, precisely because you are bold enough to look past the campaign strategy and towards the person herself.

birch, finch, beech


A very dangerous diary (4.00 / 2)
If Senator Clinton follows your advice, sir, I'm afraid that the rest of the field will begin to pale in comparison.

This is the best endorsement, for Senator Clinton, I have ever read.

Open, honest and real.

Thank you,
Jack Mitchell  

SGS is Jack Mitchell of Lowell, MA. The symbolism of the "sleeping giant" is based on my HOPE for America.


As a sports enthusiast, Jim - (4.00 / 2)
Did you hear Frank DeFord comparing candidates to sports figures on Morning Edition today?

Hillary Clinton is Dean Smith, the great North Carolina basketball coach. Dean had a strategy called the "four corners," which he would often use when he was ahead in the game. The idea was just to sit on the lead. It worked a lot, but when he was still going for his first national championship in the finals of 1977, Coach Smith went into the four corners too early and he lost to Marquette, which kept going for the basket.



Hawkeye, Iowa (0.00 / 0)
Deford compared Edwards in a one liner..."John Edwards is the Iowa Hawkeyes". So I looked it up. Not a bad comparison for the man born in Seneca, SC. His populist message hearkens back to his humble start in life. Although small he was a hard hitting starting tackle on his High School football team in Robbins, SC.

Hawkeye,Iowa was not the place Hillary had in mind when she balked at raising the Social Security cap, so middle class earners (over $97,000?) would not get a 'trillion dollar' tax increase. Its one of the small towns where so many Iowa Caucus goers live, a place where football is a religion, everyone knows each others' names, and the value of work.

Population (year 2000): 489. Estimated population in July 2006: 459 (-6.1% change)

Males: 246 (50.3%)
Females: 243 (49.7%)

Fayette County
Median resident age: 40.1 years
Iowa median age: 36.6 years

Zip codes: 52147.

Estimated median household income in 2005: $33,100 (it was $30,333 in 2000)
Hawkeye $33,100
Iowa: $43,609

Estimated median house/condo value in 2005: $57,100 (it was $48,200 in 2000)
Hawkeye $57,100
Iowa: $106,600

Next time, there may be no next time.


[ Parent ]
Fred Thompson holds the ball for place kicks! (0.00 / 0)
I loved this Frank DeFord segment and was hoping someone else would put it on Blue Hampshire as I was away from my computer...

Feeling hopeful since 2004...now "Secretary" of the New Boston Democratic Caucus

[ Parent ]
Yes, great points. (0.00 / 0)
When you have Laura Bush saying that being around the White House is good experience for the presidency, you've got to know it's a dangerous theme, unless, like Laura, you're going to play the Queen of England role with just a little less pomp and circumstance.

Why did John Kerry make a point of his military experience?  Probably because he came to realize that his efforts as a veteran were flawed because of the things he didn't know and learned later about the Viet Nam War.  So, he felt just a tad guilty and compelled to make the point that he'd MEANT well.  And that's what his contemporary enemies latched on to exploit.  They sensed a weakness and took advantage of it.

You could say that Republican politicians and their operatives always find something to attack.  That's true, but if that something has a kernel of truth and can't be dismissed as simply a lie, then the Democrat is doubly vulnerable.  If there's some convoluted strategy that says parading your weaknesses as strengths will difuse an opponent's attack, I don't get it.

It's true that George W. Bush parades his deficits.  But George W. Bush is a Republican.  Republican leaders are different from Democrats.  Their role is to accept the slings and arrows of misfortune and be undeterred by them.  Nobody, neither Republican or Democrat, actually expects them to do anything but maybe serve as a pin-cushion or target.

In his interview with Charlie Gibson on ABC, George mentioned "klieg lights" three times.  That's how he sees himself, as a target for invective (he calls it "incoming") that holds his enemies' attention so his friends can pick their pockets and make their profit.

Before the passage of the Federal Tort Claims Act and the Freedom of Information Act and the Voting Rights Act, which enable the people to keep track of what the government is doing, public officials advantaging certain segments of the public (their supporters) was standard operating procedure.  

What we now call corruption, was considered the norm--a few people ("small government") doling out the bounties of nature to their friends.  When the bounties of nature are being doled out, it isn't necessary for people to be taxed much.  It's only when services are provided by people who expect to be paid a fair wage that taxes need to be raised.

It's the pattern of transforming public assets into private wealth to which the neoconservatives would like to return.  It's what they aim to accomplish with Iraq's oil and what's happening as we speak when the mountain tops of West Virginia are removed to get at the coal.

Now there's a question to ask our presidential candidates.  What's their position on the Appaliachian Mountain tops being blown up?


Point Well Taken (4.00 / 1)
I don't think that Senator Clinton is winning the argument of ideas versus experience right now, although I can think of at least four of her proposals in Energy, Health, Privacy, and Innovation which are praised as bold creative proposals by objective observers.  My vote is not important because she has already won it. Reality is not important, if there is a perception she is not the candidate of ideas and/or change.

We have about seven weeks until the New Hampshire Presidential Primary.  That is a life time in politics.  If we are discussing this problem on Blue Hampshire, I am sure that Senator Clinton is aware of how the voters are preceiving her. She has plenty of time and money to make the argument she has the ideas and the experience to make a great president.

Senator Clinton is also starting out in this final stretch in a good place - ahead.  A clear majority of voters in a 8 candidate race is apparently finding something to like about her already. Polls will undoubtedly tighten as we get closer to the Primary, but I have confidence in Hillary Clinton as a person and as a candidate that her vision for our future will shine through and she will prevail.

We are heading out to my parents for Thanksgiving dinner. I wish everyone on Blue Hampshire a very nice holiday!


I Feel Sorry for Our Candidates Sometimes... (0.00 / 0)
Ideas DO matter, and Sen. Clinton has presented several exciting policy statements here in New Hampshire. Her speech on government reform delivered at St. Anselm's Institute of Politics was first rate. She offered a detailed plan to improve the nation's infrastructure in Rochester. Her presentation on energy policy in Portsmouth earlier this year was spectacular, a balanced call for alternative energy research and green development that would conserve energy and stimulate the economy.


Unfortunately, for most folks and certainly for much of the media, "exciting" and "policy statements" are not terms that usually go hand in hand. After the Rochester speech, a friend said his heart was racing because a presidential candidate had discussed intermodal transportation with subtlety and knowledge - okay, I know that's not a typical reaction - but I left the Portsmouth presentation exhilirated and more convinced than ever that Sen. Clinton understood the myriad issues that confront us and has concrete plans to address them.


Both of the daily papers on the Seacoast covered Sen. Clinton's energy presentation in detail, and I saw a first rate summary of the infrastructure speech in a South Carolina paper. But the stories came and went. You can find details on the senator's Web site, but, for most voters, it's as if those speeches never happened.


I wish I had a solution, but I don't. Jim's correct. Now's the time for Sen. Clinton - and the rest of our candidates - to share their ideas and vision with us. Too often, though, "the vision thing," as Poppy Bush used to say, becomes a bumper sticker phrase, and a candidate who drills deep into details is dismissed as a boring policy wonk.


Following up on Jim's baseball metaphor, Joe DiMaggio used to say he was motivated to give his best effort every day because he knew, somewhere in the stands, there was someone who'd never seen him play before and would never see him play again. Our candidates know as they criss-cross the state that there are voters who are seeing them in person for the first and perhaps only time, and they have mere minutes to close the deal.


It's not easy, as I'm sure Jim can tell us from his campaigns, and all of our candidates are struggling to find the magic. I think Sen. Clinton has done a good job sharing her command of the issues, her personality and her vision for the future with the voters, but, like all our candidates, some of her appearances have been better than others. I think she's been less erratic than many of our candidates, but even DiMaggio went 0-for-4 some days.


The task we voters have is to look at our candidates, their plans, experiences, skills and personalities in totality and make our choice. No one ever said it was easy.


Connect with BH
     
Powered by: SoapBlox