Eyes on the Prize

I was in Providence for this year’s Netroots Nation conference, one of the more than 2500 progressive activists — including a sizable contingent from New Hampshire — who gathered for three days of speeches, training sessions, panel discussions and networking.

The discussions and presentations made it clear that what we’ve experienced in New Hampshire over the last two years is not unique. It’s being played out all over the country in state after state after state: attempts to dismantle the public schools, the war on women, the fight over voting rights, the list is sadly familiar.

Van Jones delivered a powerful and succinct message in his closing keynote:

In 2012, we know. We know absolutely, with not one bit of doubt, what the agenda is. They have a wrecking ball agenda. They’ve taken a wrecking ball. They want to paint it red, white and blue, call it patriotism, and smash down every American institution our parents and our grandparents fought for. That’s what they want to do. That’s who they are. They’re proud of it. They’re not hiding it.

They say they want to smash down out unions. They want to smash down public education. They want to smash down clean air and clean water. They want to smash down everything our parents and our grandparents fought for that made this country a great county. They have it in their sights and they have shown a brutal willingness to use every means available to smash down the things that our communities need to survive.

They’ve told us. Their leader Grover Norquist says it. He says, “I want to shrink America’s government down. I want to starve it of taxes. I want to shrink it down to the size that I can drown America’s government in a bathtub. I want to drown America’s government in a bathtub.” Who thinks like that? Who even talks like that? But they’ve told us, so we know. We know.


We also know that we will be dramatically outspent in the upcoming campaign. The impact of Citizens United came up in virtually every session. Every candidate and every issue campaign is being outspent by huge margins: 5-to-1, 10-to-1 and more. The banks spent $600 million to fight financial reform compared to $2 million from progressive organizations promoting it. We know a tsunami of corporate money is about to come crashing down in support of the right’s agenda.

But we also heard success stories. Erica Payne told the story of The Agenda Project’s video opposing the Ryan budget that featured a Paul Ryan look-alike pushing granny off a cliff. It was made for just $3500 and received 20 million media impressions. The messaging was so successful that Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell publicly protested “no one is trying to throw granny off a cliff.”

The progressive online community, including this obscure little blog, has an important role to play in this election cycle in countering the onslaught of corporate money. As we begin to prepare for the upcoming campaign, the editors here are redoubling our commitment to Blue Hampshire.

That commitment includes ensuring that Blue Hampshire is a vital and welcoming destination for the state’s progressive community. As the gubernatorial primary campaign intensifies, we are determined to not let abusive and disruptive comments on this site detract from our common goal. The stakes are too high.

This is not about one candidate or the other, nor their supporters. The editors and editors emeriti are evenly split between the two leading gubernatorial candidates. But we are of one mind in that we will not, we cannot, allow the discussions on the site to deteriorate to name calling and personal attacks. Frankly, we are inclined to shoot first and ask questions later.

To those who think banning violators is too drastic, a piece by one of Blue Hampshire’s founders, Mike Caulfield, (which, unfortunately, is no longer posted on his site) has been my touchstone when the issue has come up in the past.

Your influence as a user, on a healthy site, is a function of to what extent your activity supports those group-defined social goods. In other words, to quote Shirky, the user of social software is the group, not the individual. If you are consistently acting in a way that hurts the interests of the group, the group has to defend itself. If it doesn’t, the group slowly becomes its own enemy.

This, as Shirky points out, is why government always springs up, even among anarchists. You need some form of government to protect the group from destroying itself. And if you see government as merely a pact to protect user rights, and not as something to adjudicate what Chief Justice Souter called competing goods, you’re lost.

  • hannah

    to achieve them, but that’s fairly easy to resolve by taking turns.  However, there is evil and that’s not so easy to deal with. Ignoring it certainly doesn’t work.
    When people, perhaps because they are lacking in self-awareness and cannot control themselves, seek to dominate other people and deprive them of their rights, then those people have to be interfered with, called out and brought to a halt. Self-defense doesn’t work when the object is to deprive, rather than destroy.
    I disagree with the notion that groups destroy themselves and would argue that all actions are attributable to individual persons, some of whom, apparently, have less moral sense than most natural predators, who do not prey on their own kind.
    There is something wrong with people who do that.  Letting them do it under cover of law makes it doubly wrong and a farce out of the “rule of law.”
    The law, like the group, is an impersonal designation that lets the persons who act off the hook.
    “‘Tis not I, but the law, which is lopping off your head or hoisting you upon the cross.”  Pontius Pilate is remembered for washing his hands.  For what will we remember the Governors of Texas, Perry and Bush?

  • Mike Hoefer

    Great post.

    Our goals need to be electing Annie Kuster and Carol Shea-Porter. Reelecting a Democrat as Governor*. A Majority in the EC and as many Senate and House seats we can get.

    If we use this site to share resources and tips and ideas; share our excitement and activities we have participated in or could participate in; the photos we took and first hand reports of event in support of  those goals than I believe we will have a very good night on Nov 6th.

    134 days till Election Day…

    * I kind of like that line/messaging for the Gov race. “We can’t reelect John Lynch but we can reelect a Democrat.”

  • tchair

    If not….why not !  
    There is much you can do and everyone can do something!
    Go to the state Dem web sit and find the chair of your town

    CALL !

    MAKE NEW FRIENDS !

    GET INVOLVED !

    ALL HELP IS WELCOME !

    GRASS ROOTS WORK WILL TRUMP MONEY IF YOU GET INVOLVED!!!!

    OUR DEMOCRACY IS WAY TOO IMPORTANT FOR YOU TO SIT BY AND WATCH GROVER NOQUIST DROWN IT !!!!!!!!!

  • Chaz Proulx

    Abusive comments are have increased since William posted this.

    If Blue Hampshire weren’t the only game in town I’d take a long vacation or cancel my membership altogether in protest.

    Let’s all chill for the good of this community.

    • xteeth

      Import? I have confidence that Democrats are able to keep even contradictory ideas in their heads at the same time. Life, much less political action, is not some blase walk in the park. There are differences, there are strong emotions. I think a better way to handle difference is to remember that being wrong, or asserting another’s wrongness is not an attack on their character unless that person perseverates in the wrongness and it is undefended. That is the nature of adult disputation. To do less isn’t kind it indicates lack of intensity.

Site maintenance and hosting by Hoeferweb